In Memory of Suzanne Adrienne (Lorraine) Fiumara

November 14, 2026

Resided in New York Mills, NY



Obituary

print this

Suzanne Adrienne (Lorraine) Fiumara, of New York Mills, lovingly known as “Sue” and affectionately as “Nonnie” and "Gigi" passed away peacefully on Saturday, November 14, 2026, at Wynn Hospital in Utica, surrounded by the family she adored.

To know Sue was to know pure, unconditional love, effortless laughter, and a genuinely kind heart. A radiant spirit with a playful heart and a compassionate soul, she was the bright center of her family and the angel who watched over them all. She was a friend to everyone she met, always lifting others up with her warmth, her smile, and a long chat on the phone. Her laughter was contagious. When she got into one of her laughing sprees, nobody could help but laugh right along with her. Whether she was sharing fun nights out at Packy’s Pub, cutting a rug to a classic Elvis Presley beat, or piling family members into their SAAB convertible for rides to view Christmas lights, unriddle a mystery, or head out to the beach, Sue knew how to turn every moment into a joyful memory.

Alongside her beloved husband, Anthony “Tony” Fiumara, Suzanne built a rich, lively life filled with shared passions and hard work. Together, they ventured into the restaurant business as the proud owners of Fiumara Manor in Kirkland. More than just a business, it became a special gathering place for family and friends, where everyone pitched in to be a part of the family venture and the grand kids could always be found running around. Outside of the restaurant, Sue dedicated her long career to caring for people, first working within the hospital system and later in private duty nursing, where she brought unwavering dignity, compassion, and grace to the aging population at the end of their lives.

At home in New York Mills, Sue’s door was always open, and her kitchen was the heart of countless cherished memories. Whether she was preparing a grand Christmas dinner of her lasagna and ham (famously keeping her Christmas tree up long past the holidays until the needles were completely bare), hosting Italian Sunday dinners with the best traditional oil and vinegar salad and burnt garlic bread in town, sitting on her favorite stool sipping a dry red, enjoying a day out shopping with her grand kids, or whipping up the world’s best egg salad sandwiches on the fly when family dropped in unannounced, she made sure no one ever left hungry, unloved, or without a smile.

She had an unforgettable sense of fun and style. She could rock a fedora better than anyone, delighted everyone with her creative homemade Halloween costumes over the years (including memorable turns as Dorothy, the Tin Man, and Tina Turner), and famously pulled out the same vintage lily pad bikini during family vacations to Myrtle Beach, true to her signature habit of saving everything and making the most of what she had. Her greatest joy in life was simply being surrounded by the people she loved most, making each of her grandchildren and great-grandchildren feel like the center of her universe.

Sue taught each and every one of her loved ones something special. She taught them how to love with every ounce of their hearts, how to help others regardless of the burden or stress it might bring, and how to stand up for the people they love. She guided her family with grace, teaching them to hold one another close and to never give up, reminding them they are always stronger than they could ever imagine. Those lessons do not fade with her passing; they remain her greatest gift, living on in the character of her children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and every person whose life she touched.

She leaves behind a legacy of warmth, generosity, and boundless devotion. Sue is survived by her devoted husband, Anthony “Tony” Fiumara; her three loving daughters, Patricia Bonner and her husband, Robert, of Frankfort, Lorraine Wheatley and her partner, Jim Purcell, of Whitesboro, and her “baby,” Karen Wheatley, and her partner, John Carey, of Cassville, with whom she shared an undeniable bond. She is also survived by her daughter-in-law, Robin Wheatley; her brothers, Jim Lorraine and his wife, Sandi, of Sauquoit, Mark Lorraine of Little Valley; and her devoted sister, Julie Dwyer and her husband, Dave, of New Hartford.  

Sue shared a deeply special bond with her seven grandchildren: Krystal Curley and her husband, Chris, of Utica; Danielle Lansdall of Ilion; Christopher Lansdall and his wife, Kayla, of Ilion; Amanda Barney and her partner, Cody Buress, of Cassville; Joel Barney and his partner, Nicole Nobles, of Cape Coral, FL; Adrienna Barney; and Jordan Wheatley and his wife, Rebecca, of Richfield Springs. She also leaves behind 16 treasured great-grandchildren, a large extended step-family, and her dear, lifelong friend, Kathy Sealy of Whitesboro.

Sue was predeceased by her parents, Virginia and Jack Lorraine Sr. of New Hartford; her sister, Jeanne Lorraine of Sauquoit; her brother, Jack Lorraine Jr. of Canastota; the father of her children and her former husband, William “Bill” Wheatley Sr. of Clinton; and her beloved son, William “Billy” Wheatley Jr. of New Hartford.

Now at peace in heaven’s gentle light, her warmth stays with us in every smile and shared memory.  

The funeral will be on Friday, November 20, at 9:00 am at Mary, Mother of Our Savior Parish, 2222 Genesee St, Utica, where a Funeral Mass will be celebrated.  Interment will be in Norwich Corners Cemetery.  Calling hours will be on Thursday, November 19, from 4:00 pm to 6:00 pm at Friedel, Williams & Edmunds Funeral and Cremation Services, 13 Oxford Rd., New Hartford.

For online expressions of sympathy go to fwefh.com.